Happy Face, Was It Worth It?

In this chilling series premiere, a mysterious birthday card ultimately forces Melissa, Hazel's mother, to confront the dark truth of her past.

On their trip to Texas, Melissa and Ivy discover something intriguing about Heather Richmond’s murder. What they find pushes Melissa to step into the light.

Melissa faces challenges in sharing her story publicly. The team questions Elijah’s innocence while Keith gets thrown into solitary confinement.

Melissa reconnects with her brother and confronts her father, who eventually gives a clue about the case. Hazel gets a surprise invitation.

When crucial evidence goes missing, Melissa creates an unlikely partnership. Elijah weighs a plea deal. Hazel begins a secret correspondence.

Unknown footage of Heather surfaces during Melissa and Ivy's search. Elijah gets his day in court. Ben receives bad news. Joyce's secret is revealed.

A dark family secret draws Melissa back to Ash. Ben takes extreme measures to protect his family. The case takes yet another turn.

In this thrilling season finale, Melissa seems to have cracked the case. Keith is attacked, and Ben faces the challenges of his actions.